Race on Ice (and in the Stands)

Last night the Washington Capitals defeated the Boston Bruins 2-1 in overtime to win their first round Stanley Cup series.  Joel Ward scored the overtime winner, banging in a rebound past Tim Thomas.

I thought that the goal might prove controversial given the contact between Washington forward Mike Knuble and Thomas: it seemed to me that the collision between the two left Thomas unable to do much to stop Ward’s shot.  A few people agreed, but there was nothing said about that on the broadcast.  Nor was there anything said about the fact that Joel Ward is of African descent.

At least, not on the air.  In cyberspace, where everyone becomes brave behind a keyboard, not everyone let Ward’s race go unnoticed.  Several Bruins fans were so upset that they went ballistic … and raciston Twitter.  That’s right … Twitter.

(Anyone who thinks that I overlook racism in the North will have to revise that claim.)

The owner of the Capitals denounced the taunts; so did Bruins management in a blunt if brief statement.  Ward dismissed the comments: “We won, and we are moving on. People are going to say what they want to say.”

Of course, in the response to the racist outburst by some Bruins fans (and, one speculates, some non-Bruins fans), some other people began to lash back at Bruins fans, period.  There was some justice in this, as a good number of Bruins fans (joined by other fans) had derided Vancouver Canucks hockey fans at the conclusion of last year’s Stanley Cup finals, when some Canucks fans (joined, one suspects, by people who couldn’t care less about hockey) rioted and looted through their home city in the aftermath of their Game Seven defeat in the Finals (a riot that was something to follow on Twitter as well).  So turnabout seemed to be fair play if nothing else.  It took some time for folks to understand that a few bad apples don’t necessarily spoil the whole bunch, although they sure don’t help sell the product.  One Yahoo Sports columnist made that point rather well in a column.  Others seemed torn between the temptation to retaliate and the realization that it may be best to ignore such bigotry.  Another commentator made more complex and to my mind problematic points.

We see the same thing all the time when discussing southern “heritage” advocates.   I’ve anticipated the point made by the Yahoo columnist, Harrison Mooney, and do what I can to make sure that when I’m writing about some Confederate heritage activists, I’m focusing on certain individuals, not everyone who is seeking ways to recognize what they define as Confederate heritage (enough with conflating this with southern heritage).  Those people I criticize would like you to believe otherwise in an effort to play the victim and gain sympathy in some quarters–thus all this tripe about Dixie-bashing and evilizing the South and similar garbage that reflects their own attitude formed by fear, bitterness, and hatred (along with a strong dose of ignorance and stupidity).  But SCV members chat with me all the time, and they know better.  That said, it also behooves those very people who deplore the association of Confederate heritage with such people to make public their disgust with such folks when their language smacks of racism, bigotry, and/or violent threats.

Me?  I admit I thought along racial lines when Ward scored against Thomas (although that came later, when I was reflecting on what had happened: to me it was first and foremost a hockey play, period, and these thoughts did not come until I was becoming bored by Mike Milbury and Jeremy Roenick jabbering away on a postgame show).  After all, Thomas had snubbed President Barack Obama by not accompanying his team to the White House earlier this year in the traditional US Stanley Cup championship team meets president ceremony (a tradition started by the New York Islanders during the Reagan administration).  His grounds were explicitly political.  Washington fans had not forgotten.  So I wondered whether people would note that a black man representing Washington achieved a form of payback by beating Thomas … especially one wearing #42.  That would be even more ironic given that it was the Bruins who were the first team to have a player of African descent play for them when Willie O’Ree joined the club back in 1958.  Nah, I thought, that’s just the overactive mind of a historian who happens to be a hockey fan (or a hockey fan who happens to be a historian) … no one else would see it this way (it’s been a long term complaint that the president has not appeared at a Capitals game).  Apparently some did (at least partially, although I don’t think I’ve seen mention of Ward’s jersey number).  As for the rest, no, I didn’t anticipate it.  Sometimes my desire to think better of people obscures a sadder reality about some of them.  Maybe that’s why skeptics are never disappointed, only surprised.

6 thoughts on “Race on Ice (and in the Stands)

  1. martin April 27, 2012 / 4:36 am

    “… Sigh. White people”

  2. Lyle Smith April 27, 2012 / 7:23 am

    Personally (not that I think you disagree Professor) I think the rioting that happened in Vancouver last year was way worse. I think it is abhorrent of these fans to call a black player a nigger, but it’s not beating someone up or destroying someone’s property. Of course anyone, including Vancouver fans, can pile on to Bruin fans over this.

    I also hope these New Englanders (I think it is fair to call these Bruin fans New Englanders; one guy is from Connecticut) who called the man a nigger were only young people, and just super immature and irresponsible in their social media use. It’s not like the word is not out there and used in popular culture by a variety of people today. So I can see someone grabbing hold of it and using it in a moment of super stupidity. That doesn’t make it right of course, but maybe helps explains why they’re comfortable using the word on twitter.

    • Brooks D. Simpson April 27, 2012 / 11:11 am

      The name calling was not limited to New Englanders or to Bruins fans. That, of course, is one aspect of the unfolding narrative that was slighted in these stories.

  3. John Foskett April 27, 2012 / 7:56 am

    Unfortunately the sports media (using its usual slipshod investigative techniques) may have painted with too broad a brush here. Most of the offending Twitter accounts apparently now have been shut down. Before they were, however, it became clear that this was not limited to so-called “Bruins fans”. One of these losers, for example, had Red Wings logo all over the place. Another was a Sabres fanboy. Some were located in Canada. In addition, some were by juveniles who were also tweeting about their farts, etc. This problem ain’t, with all due respect to the sports media,, a Boston problem (although that’s the lazy man’s road of ease to spouting a column). One need only recall the jackass at the Flyers exhibition game last September in Hamilton, ON (IIRC) who tossed a banana on the ice in the direction of Wayne Simmonds. Bottom line – there are racist morons everywhere, especially in the sports fanbase which, unfortunately, tends to the lowest common denominator. Trivia question, by the way, for those who recall that Mr. Yawkey’s Red Sox were the last baseball team to integrate. Which team suited up the first African American in the NHL? .

    • Brooks D. Simpson April 27, 2012 / 11:12 am

      The answer to the trivia question is in my post. In fact, the Bruins integrated before the Red Sox did.

      • John Foskett April 27, 2012 / 1:59 pm

        Missed that. I have always found that fact intriguing. It’s not so much that the Adams family was a bunch of rights crusaders (and God knows they weren’t looking to pay anybody one red cent – I’m sure you know the story about Sinden calling Boston from Parry Sound to discuss which exchange rate to use when signing a 14-year-old defenseman). It’s that Yawkey was an out and out racist.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s