Predictable Patterns

Hayes TnSomeone called my attention to a recent thread on about Mayor Curtis Hayes of Livingston, Tennessee, accepting his membership in the Sons of Confederate Veterans. Mayor Hayes is an African American. The story is old news from 2009.

The ensuing thread of comments follows a predictable pattern. Research reveals that the ancestor in question (one Sam Cullom) was a recipient of a Tennessee pension for African Americans, not a veteran’s pension, and that there is no record of his service as a Confederate soldier. Others argue that to highlight the ancestor’s actual status is to quibble with the fact that the ancestor “served,” regardless of the capacity in which he served.

In short, some folks want to reclassify those who “served” as “soldiers” regardless of the historical reality that the people in question simply were not soldiers, imposing their present needs and desire on the past … and historical accuracy be damned. I can’t wait to hear some of them whine “political correctness” when they argue that the same practices are being embraced by people with whom they disagree.

And, of course, at times the conversation goes in other directions (just as it sometimes goes in the comments section here).

Anyway, as I’ve learned that CivilWarTalk (like Yahoo’s civilwarhistory2) sometimes links to blog entries here in order to foster conversation over there, I thought I’d return the favor.

2 thoughts on “Predictable Patterns

  1. Neil Hamilton June 28, 2013 / 1:16 am

    Professor Simpson,

    Thanks for returning the favor to us forum members of Civil War You have often provided articles and sources that contribute to our understanding and history of the Civil War.

    Thank you for all your assistance.

    Neil Hamilton aka civilwartalk forum member, Unionblue

  2. TF Smith July 2, 2013 / 1:07 pm

    I’m sure there is an “old campaigners” organization for the SS; rather doubt very many descendants of any surviving kapos would join up…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s