October 23, 1863 October 23, 2013Brooks D. Simpson Identify the people in the picture … then provide your own caption. Share this:FacebookTwitterEmailLike this:Like Loading... Related
Sorry, can’t identify them all. Do recognize Grant in front of the fireplace, Thomas standing to the right of the mantle and “Baldy” Smith to the left. On the 23rd, Grant met with his officers in Chattanooga. During the meeting, some of them indicated a route (or routes) by which Rosecrans had planned to evacuate the city. “They pointed out on the map the line marked with red or blue pencil,” Grant later wrote.
Grant in front of the fireplace, Thomas next to it on right. Is that O. O Howard on the far left?
Grant is telling the officer taking his hat off to shut the door…asking if he was born in a barn.
Grant and Thomas inviting Rosecrans to fling himself into the fire.
As Howard, Grant, and Thomas ponder the supply of Chattanooga, the tabled general exclaims
” Well the tea leaves, AND the bell, book, and candle predict Sherman will take Atlanta AND
burn it to the ground. —Incredible!”
Enters a stranger:
“How do you do. My name is Orlando Poe, on my way back to Knoxville.”
From left to right: Charles A. Dana (?) (foreground), J. A. Rawlins, James H. Wilson, William F. Smith, U. S. Grant, George H. Thomas, Horace Porter.
Officer (Porter?) entering the room: “There is a woman outside name of Chastain. Says she has a wagon load of flags for you.”
Grant, gesturing toward the fireplace: “Grand! I have just the place for them!”
Thomas to Poe: “Nobody brought a match. Care to help the General light his stogie?”
I’m sure Grant’s thinking don’t let the door hit ya where the good lord split ya.
Doh, I thought the guy bidding farewell must have been Rosecrans, but Grant met him en route. Who is that?
From left to right, John A. Rawlins, Charles A. Dana, James H. Wilson, William F. “Baldy” Smith, Grant, Thomas, and Captain Horace Porter. The image appeared as an illustration in Porter’s book “Campaigning with Grant,” and depicts the book’s opening scene, in which Porter was summoned to Thomas’s headquarters in Chattanooga and met Grant for the first time. So my caption for the picture would be “A Hero-Worshipper Meets His Subject.”
Two guys with an awkward mutual dislike (Grant and Thomas) joyously greet the arrival of a third party (Porter) so they won’t have to talk to each other.
Are we sure that is Wilson? Doesn’t look like other pics of him I have seen. I agree on the others, although I would not have recognized Dana. I like Norm’s idea for a caption.